Bruskotter , J.T., Vucetich, J.A., Naughton-Treves, L., López-Bao, J.V., Ghasemi, B., Sintov, N.D., Teel, T.L., Carter, N.H., Elbroch, L.M. and Treves, A., 2026. Toward a Synthetic Theory of Tolerance for Carnivores: Learning from a Half-Century of Research on Attitudes Toward Wolves. Conservation, 6(2), p.4
ABSTRACT
Abstract
Human intolerance is a critical factor limiting both the distributions and populations of large carnivores. Using gray wolves as a case study, we synthesize a half-century of scholarship with the aims of clarifying the conceptual foundations of “tolerance” and integrating insights from across the social sciences. Specifically, we review longitudinal studies of attitudes toward wolves and show how trends vary across the populations examined. We then identify and discuss three complementary theories that help explain variation in tolerance across individuals, social groups, and societies: (1) Risk–benefit theories illuminate how perceptions of risks, benefits, and controllability shape individuals’ tolerance of carnivores; (2) Modernization theory explains societal shifts in values and shows how reduced threats from carnivores impact tolerance at the societal level; and (3) Social Identity Theory highlights how identification with interest groups (e.g., hunters, environmentalists) shape beliefs in a manner that serves to exacerbate inter-group conflicts. Linking these theoretical perspectives provides a more holistic framework for understanding why tolerance can change within populations, and why inter-group conflicts persist even as societal attitudes have become more favorable. We conclude by outlining research priorities aimed at improving our understanding of tolerance and the conditions that allow for human–carnivore coexistence.
A Change in the Image of the Wolf (Canis lupus) in the Poles’ Public Awareness-the Demand for Environmental Education. Klimski M, Gadziński M. Studia Ecologiae et Bioethicae. 2025 Sep
ABSTRACT
Abstract
The public awareness of the grey wolf (Canis lupus) is shaped by various messages. Among these, undoubtedly the most influential are those related to repeated stereotypes, often based on unverified sources or even misinformation. As a consequence, it leads to numerous human-wolf conflicts. The aim of this article is to highlight the role of environmental education, conducted in its various forms, in changing the social perception of Canis lupus. The paradox observed in the public image of the wolf somewhat compels the implementation of effective environmental education with a view toward its protection. An analytical-synthetic method was applied in this paper, which enabled the formulation of conclusions from the collected research material. Among these are findings indicating that building a positive image of the predator should be based on reliable scientific data. Moreover, selecting appropriate educational methods and forms allows scientific data to be presented to all recipients of the educational process, from the youngest children to adults. Consequently, environmental education delivered in this way to various social groups shapes a proper image of the key predator of the forest ecosystem—the grey wolf.
Perception toward wolves are driven by economic status and religion across their distribution range. Naha D, Döringer S, Heurich M. Animals. 2025 Apr
ABSTRACT
Abstract
Effective conservation of large mammals depends on how people perceive them. Grey wolves have a widespread distribution globally, and their recent recolonization of human-dominated landscapes offers an excellent opportunity to understand the heterogeneity in their perception across continents. Our analysis included all quantitative studies (118 articles) conducted in 35 countries through a systematic review process, published globally between 1980–2023 and indexed in Web of Science and Google Scholar. Fifty-four percent of the studies reported a negative perception toward wolves. Most studies conducted in Asia reported a negative perception, while 56% of studies conducted in Europe and 48% in North America reported a positive perception. Fifty-four percent of studies from Western Europe and forty percent of studies from Slavic Russian cultural regions reported positive perceptions. Respondents from low-income countries elicited the most negative perceptions. We identified the predominant religion and economic status of a country as dominant factors determining perception. Studies conducted in countries with Hinduism as the predominant religion reported a negative perception toward wolves. We recommend that future studies on human–wolf interactions must prioritize regions within central Europe, parts of Asia, and Russia. A global human–wolf coexistence strategy should consider the social factors driving attitude toward the species.
Drivers of human attitudes towards wolves Canis lupus in Kazakhstan. Koshkina A, Kudrenko S, Ordiz A, Kamiyeva S, Devenish A, Champ J. People and Nature. 2025 Mar
ABSTRACT P
Abstract
Kazakhstan is recognized as a key stronghold for the grey wolf (Canis lupus). Nonetheless, the wolf status and the dynamics of human-wolf coexistence in the region remain poorly understood. This study aims to fill that gap by exploring current attitudes towards wolves in Kazakhstan and identify the underlying drivers of these attitudes.We collected information using a survey questionnaire (in person and online) from 1068 individuals across various demographic groups, including rural and urban residents, hunters and livestock owners. The survey was conducted across the country's three main landscapes—steppe, desert and high mountains to ensure a diverse and representative sample of perspectives.Our findings indicate that respondents generally held neutral or positive views about wolves and their presence in Kazakhstan. However, attitudes towards coexistence with wolves in respondents' home regions were notably more negative. Livestock owners exhibited the most antagonistic attitudes towards wolf presence in their home regions. These attitudes were primarily influenced by wildlife value orientations, fear and knowledge of wolf behaviour.Synthesis and applications. Our findings highlight the need for further research to develop strategies for fostering human-wolf coexistence in Kazakhstan. Key priorities include: (1) investigating the causes and drivers of wolf attacks on humans, with particular attention to the role of rabies; (2) evaluating the effectiveness of traditional and innovative approaches to preventing livestock predation in Kazakh rangelands; and (3) collecting data on wolf distribution and population densities to inform evidence-based management strategies. These efforts will contribute to the sustainable management of wolf populations, balancing conservation objectives with the concerns of local communities.
Are Wolves the Real Problem? Challenges Faced by Livestock Farmers Living Alongside Wolves in Northwestern Greece. Petridou M, Kati V. Sustainability 2025
Social and ecological influences on human coexistence with gray wolves. Riley SJ, Kellner KF, Cross M, Pomeranz EF, Belant JL. Conservation Science and Practice. 2025 Oct
ABSTRACT
Abstract
We assessed public attitudes toward gray wolves (Canis lupus) in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula, focusing on how perceived risks, habitat suitability as a proxy for probability of human–wolf interactions, and socio-cultural factors affected societal acceptance of wolf populations. A survey (n = 883; response rate = 26.9%) revealed 61.7% of respondents favored reducing wolf abundance, driven primarily by concerns over risks to livestock, White-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus), and human safety. Conversely, those who valued the ecological role of wolves were less inclined to support population reductions. Perceived risks, particularly to deer, strongly influenced attitudes. Wolf habitat suitability correlated with a greater desire for population reduction. Our predictive model, incorporating perceived risks and habitat suitability, demonstrated high accuracy (area under the curve = 0.94). Findings in the context of other research on human–wolf interactions suggest wolf management will be more effective if it addresses specific local concerns, such as deer and livestock, and employs continuous public engagement. Public engagement, especially in rural areas, is essential to build trust and improve understanding of wolf conservation. Integrating local concerns into broader policy and management strategies can foster coexistence and reduce conflicts, ultimately supporting wolf conservation and community well-being.
.Visitors to national parks show positive attitudes towards recolonising wolves in the Bohemian Forest Ecosystem. Bacon S, Smith AF, Döringer S, Bečka P, Hußlein M, Porst F, Stemberg J, Heurich M. Biological Conservation. 2023 Dec
ABSTRACT
Wolves (Canis lupus) are recolonising large swathes of their former European territories after a lengthy absence. This expanding distribution brings wolves to areas of naïve human communities, inflating risks to human-wildlife coexistence. As such, understanding public attitudes and perspectives to wolf return is central to supporting human-wildlife coexistence. Wolves returned to Germany in 2000 and sporadically to Czech Republic in the 1990s, but only few studies have assessed public attitudes. No research from a protected area visitor perspective has been conducted in Europe, despite their importance for outdoor recreation and nature conservation. We conducted face-to-face surveys of visitors, administered by enumerators during 2018–2019 (n = 869) in the Bavarian Forest and Šumava National Parks, which form a transboundary protected area along the German-Czech border, where the first wolves re-established in 2015. Primarily, we applied aspects of attitude theory, focusing on the components of attitudes (ABC Model of Attitudes) to examine support for wolves from national park visitors (locally and nationally) and if the visitors’ attitudes towards wolves differ. We found substantial support for wolves recolonising Germany and Czech Republic (84.5 %), and agreement that wolves belong in these national parks (89.6 %). Attitudes varied most by country of residence, with Czech visitors more supportive than Germans. Transboundary management which recognises the human dimensions of large carnivore conservation is crucial to supporting coexistence. We highlight the importance of understanding the diverse sociocultural backgrounds across Europe which may influence attitudes towards wolves, and nature conservation areas to support long-term transboundary management policies, coexistence goals, and education.
Coexistence conservation: Reconciling threatened species and invasive predators through adaptive ecological and evolutionary approaches. Evans MJ, Weeks AR, Scheele BC, Gordon IJ, Neaves LE, Andrewartha TA, Brockett B, Rapley S, Smith KJ, Wilson BA, Manning AD. Conservation Science and Practice. 2022 Jul
Assessing key drivers of human attitudes towards large carnivores in Finland. Heikkilä, S., 2020
DECADE OF USE OF DAMAGE PREVENTION MEASURES IN SPAIN AND PORTUGAL. Cortés, Y., Ribeiro, S., Petrucci-Fonseca, F. and Blanco, J.C., A 2020
Avoiding negativity bias: Towards a positive psychology of human–wildlife relationships. Buijs A, Jacobs M. Ambio. 2020 Oct
Attitudes of the General Public and Hunters Towards Wolves in Latvia; Its Predictors and Changes Over Time. Žunna A, Bagrade G, Ozoliņš J.InProceedings of the Latvian Academy of Sciences. Section B. Natural, Exact, and Applied Sciences. 2020 Aug
Wolves are back: Sociopolitical identity and opinions on management of Canis lupus. Hamilton LC, Lambert JE, Lawhon LA, Salerno J, Hartter J. Conservation Science and Practice. 2020 Apr
Attitudes toward and Knowledge about Wolves in SW German Secondary School Pupils from within and outside an Area Occupied by Wolves (Canis lupus). Randler C, Wagner A, Rögele A, Hummel E, Tomažič I. Animals. 2020 Apr
Factors affecting attitudes toward reintroduction of wolves in Japan. Sakurai R, Tsunoda H, Enari H, William FS, Uehara T, Stedman RC. Global Ecology and Conservation. 2020 Mar
Drivers of intervention use to protect domestic animals from large carnivore attacks. Eklund A, Johansson M, Flykt A, Andrén H, Frank J. Human Dimensions of Wildlife. 2020 Feb
Resident cognitions associated with branding Thompson, Manitoba as the Wolf Capital of the World. Bishop B, Vaske JJ, Bath AJ. Human Dimensions of Wildlife. 2020 Jan
HTML] Blood may buy goodwill: no evidence for a positive relationship between legal culling and poaching in Wisconsin
A Stien – Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological …, 2017
Changes in attitudes toward wolves before and after an inaugural public hunting and trapping season: early evidence from Wisconsin’s wolf range
J Hogberg, A Treves, B Shaw… – Environmental …, 2016
Tolerance of wolves in Wisconsin: a mixed-methods examination of policy effects on attitudes and behavioral inclinations
C Browne-Nuñez, A Treves, D MacFarland… – Biological …, 2015 – Elsevier
The price of tolerance: wolf damage payments after recovery. Treves A, Jurewicz RL, Naughton-Treves L, Wilcove DS. Biodiversity and Conservation. 2009 Dec
Human attitudes towards wolves, a matter of distance. Karlsson J, Sjöström M. Biological conservation. 2007 Jul
Paying for tolerance: rural citizens’ attitudes toward wolf depredation and compensation. NAUGHTON‐TREVES LI, Grossberg R, Treves A. Conservation biology. 2003 Dec
Japanese peoples’ attitudes toward wolves and their reintroduction into Japan. Angeli CB, Maruyama N, Koganezawa M, Takahashi M, Chinen S. Biosphere conservation: for nature, wildlife, and humans. 1998
